Netflix's animated Christmas film "That Christmas" has sparked outrage for allegedly disrespecting Christian beliefs and mocking the birth of Jesus Christ. Released on December 4, the movie is based on the children’s book series by Richard Curtis, the acclaimed director of Love Actually (2003). The film’s controversial content has led to widespread protests, particularly from Christian communities.
Controversial Depiction of the Nativity Scene
The story begins with a group of schoolchildren, led by a teenager named Bernadette, rewriting the traditional biblical Nativity story. The display portrays Jesus as a "cool dude" and criticizes his image as a reformer, referencing his beard and long hair. Bernadette challenges the audience by asking, "Wouldn’t Jesus be interested in retelling the same boring Christmas story every year?" She proposes a more inclusive cultural celebration featuring pop songs and discussions about climate change.
The depiction of other biblical characters also strays from traditional narratives. The shepherds are shown as vegetable farmers, and the three wise men are portrayed as women, directly contradicting the Bible. Additionally, the character playing the Virgin Mary sings about her pregnancy to Madonna’s controversial 1986 song “Don’t Advise Me, Pope,” which has further angered viewers.
Accusations of Insulting Christian Beliefs
Christian groups and individuals have voiced strong opposition to the film. Mary-Logan Miske, a formation coordinator at the Southeast Campus of Students for Life of America, stated on social media that the film crosses all boundaries of decency by mocking the sacred Nativity story. Blaze Media co-founder Allen Mashburn criticized parents for continuing to subscribe to Netflix and warned of a hidden agenda behind the film’s content.
Madonna's Role Adds Fuel to the Fire
The soundtrack, helmed by pop icon Madonna, has been another focal point of criticism. Madonna, known for her outspoken support of abortion and anti-Christian themes in her music, has long been a polarizing figure. In 2019, she called on the Catholic Church to revise its stance on abortion during an Australian talk show. Her inclusion in the film has been interpreted as an intentional affront to Christian values.
Netflix’s Silence Amid Backlash
Despite the growing protests, Netflix has yet to issue a statement addressing the controversy. Critics argue that the platform’s silence only adds to the frustration of those who feel their beliefs have been disrespected. The film has ignited a broader conversation about the portrayal of religious themes in modern media and the boundaries of artistic expression.
The song takes on a poignant and thought-provoking tone, told from the perspective of a young woman who finds herself in a precarious situation. With vulnerability and honesty, she confides in her father about an unexpected pregnancy, revealing the turmoil and uncertainty that comes with it. However, in a bold and resolute declaration, she shares her decision to forgo abortion and instead choose life for her unborn child. The song's powerful narrative is further underscored by a symbolic and evocative gesture at its conclusion. In a clever and creative twist, the girl portraying Mary holds up a watermelon, serving as a potent representation of the baby Jesus and driving home the song's themes of hope, redemption, and the sanctity of life.